Does your character have any visible scars, physical defects, or non-human qualities? hahah OK so Maglor is a Tolkien elf - soooo (1) inhumanly beautiful, looks *physically* in his late 20s/early 30s, but Sherlock would probably be able to tell somethings off? (2) pointed ears (3) he doesn't move human, unless he's actively trying to blend in (4) he's got a nasty burn scar on his right hand, that looks hella old but also that it has been & keeps being reopeneded (5) He's got both sword and harp calluses on his hands - and Sherlock can probably tell that he's right hand dominant, but uses his left now predominantly (6) he doesn't glow in Asgard, but if he gets his blood up his eyes are inhumanly bright
What was/is their profession or occupation? right *now* he's a soldier again, but he spent several centuries prior to Asgard wandering up and down the seashore as a bard, and several centuries before *that* as a warrior prince.
Is there anything about themselves they would deliberately try to hide or lie about? Maglor won't lie, but he won't bring up his past unless asked
Are they more neat than sloppy, or more sloppy than neat? Clothing and weaponry wise, very neat. Everything else is "absent minded artist" - he still prefers quill and parchment, for example, although he's slowly using ball point pens now, and Sherlock might find the odd ink spot on his clothes.
Is there anything you the player specifically want him NOT to notice? nope!